top of page

Magic Singles

Buying Singles From Us

We sell individual Magic The Gathering cards of all varieties. Whether you need a list of cards to finish a deck, want to start a new Commander list, or need some land, we've got you covered.

If the list of cards you need is relatively short (think under 15 cards), you're more than welcome to stop by anytime and we'll take care of you.


For longer lists, or if you'd like the ease of ordering online, you're encouraged to send your lists to us ahead of time either through the content form on this page or by emailing


When you send your list digitally, it allows us to prep it for you ahead of time, let you know the missing cards and total, and notify you once it's ready. From that point, you can stop by anytime to retrieve it. We'll hold it for up to 48 hours.

Selling Singles To Us

If you have Magic The Gathering cards you want to get rid of, we're happy to take a look and purchase any cards we want from you with either in-store credit or cash. We reserve the right to turn down buys, typically in the case of large collections, bulk commons/uncommons, or cards in damaged condition.​

We take in singles based on TCGplayer Market Pricing. For store credit, you'll get 60% on cards over $2.


Under $2, we may not take the card, otherwise, we'll pay our bulk rate of $0.10 per card.


In cash, you'll get 40% on most singles over $2. We don't take singles under $2 for cash, and high-end cards (over $100) are eligible for a custom quote.

We cannot provide a quote over email or phone, so you'll need to bring them into the store for us to take a look. This is done so we can ensure the condition, quality, and authenticity of the cards and get you the most accurate possible pricing information. We always have someone on staff who can take a look, so feel free to stop by anytime.

Thank you for contacting us! We will get back to you as soon as possible, typically within 24 hours.

bottom of page